13 Of The Most Haunted Places In Indiana [With Proof]

Last Updated on November 21, 2022 by Urbex Underground

If you’re searching for haunted places in Indiana, we’ve got you covered! Below are 13 different haunted places you can explore across the great state of Indiana along with their status and exact GPS coordinates.

History:

Located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, the Slippery Noodle Inn has been in operation since 1850. This historic building was once a bordello, but has since transformed into one of the top blues clubs in the country.

Slippery Noodle Inn has been owned by the Yeagy family since 1963. Hal Yeagy took over in 1985 after his father’s death. Since then, the Yeagy family has run the Noodle, and it is still a family-run business today.

Evidence:

The Noodle Inn has a rich history that includes the use of the basement as a way station on the Underground Railroad. This building has been the site of paranormal experiences and has been the site of a number of investigations.

There have been reports of people claiming to see ghosts of enslaved people and prostitutes. There have been reports of a caretaker who still works at the building, and there have also been reports of people hearing whispers and voices.

---

History:

The French Lick Springs Hotel is famous for its beautiful architecture. It is one of the oldest buildings in the town and was built in 1845. The original hotel was destroyed in a fire. After the fire, the hotel underwent extensive renovations. The new French Lick Springs Hotel has retained its historical charm while adding a modern, yet haunted touch.

Proof:

The most haunted part of the French Lick Springs Hotel is located on the sixth floor. Many guests have reported a ghostly apparition that can be seen walking around the hotel and the service elevator. There have also been reports of phantom footsteps and unexplained cold spots.

There are also reports of a shadow apparition seen on the sixth floor. Other ghostly sightings at the hotel include disembodied voices and unexplained phantom cigar tobacco smells. The hotel is also reputed to be haunted by the former owner of the hotel, Thomas Taggart.

---

History:

Located in Amity, Indiana, The Grave in the Middle of the Road has been around for over one hundred years. It’s been a popular hangout for road workers, curious kids, and college students in search of a supernatural specter.

One of the most intriguing aspects of The Grave in the Middle of the Road is the fact that it contains the remains of seven people, all of which were re-interred into new caskets.

Although no one has yet come forward with the story of how the site got its start, the mystery remains unsolved. A team of archaeologists at the University of Indianapolis stumbled upon the site while conducting a test run to widen a road. The team found seven bodies, including two women, a man, and four children. 

Proof:

Evidence of paranormal hasn’t been well documented given the grave’s dangerous locations. However, that hasn’t stopped various stories and rumors from taking shape over time.

---

History:

Throughout the years, America’s prisons have been haunted by the darkness and evil housed behind their walls. One example is the haunted Old Blackford County Jail in Hartford City, Indiana. This jail was built in the mid-1870s and was used as a detention center for inmates.

One of the haunts at the jail is a ghostly man who has been seen sitting in the lobby of the jail. It is also said that the ghost of a handyman who died in 1910 has been seen working on things. A never-ending repair list if you will.

One of the most popular paranormal theories is the Stone Tape Theory, which claims that certain rocks replay energies that have been recorded on them. Some witnesses have reported electrical devices turning on and off by themselves.

Proof:

---

History:

The Allison Mansion was built between 1911 and 1914, in the Arts and Crafts style. The interior of the house includes a Louis XVI-style parlor, a Gothic-style library, and a hand-carved walnut staircase.

Its exterior was designed by renowned Indianapolis architect Herbert Bass. The mansion’s interior was finished by Philadelphia architect William Price. The property also features an automatic lighting closet, an indoor swimming pool, and an elevator.

James Allison died from pneumonia in 1928 at the age of 56. His family kept the mansion until 1936, when it was sold to the Sisters of St. Francis of Oldenberg. It became the administration building and living quarters for the college. The building was later converted into a library.

Proof:

The Allison Mansion is said to be haunted by the ghost of a young girl who drowned in a basement pool. Some visitors have claimed to hear her cries, while others say that they have seen her dripping wet in the basement.

There have been reports of furniture moving and items appearing and disappearing. The attic area has been said to be filled with disembodied voices, and is a recorded hot spot.

---

History:

Located in Martinsville, Indiana, Stepp Cemetery has long been rumored to be haunted. According to legend, a young girl was murdered in the area and her body was dumped nearby. There is no proof of the crime, but there is a well-preserved grave of the victim.

Another legend has it that the lady in black spent hours perched on a tree stump near her grave and her husband would talk to her. While the stories involving ghosts and orbs are all the rage these days, Stepp Cemetery has a long history of spooky sightings dating back nearly 100 years.

Proof:

---

History:

The Whispers Estate is considered one of the most haunted places in the state. This 3700-square-foot Victorian-designed home is known to have been home to several ghosts. The property has also been featured on a number of television shows including Ghost Stories 2, Syfy, and Travel Channel.

One of the most notable features of this property is the whispering walls. Many visitors have reported hearing things whisper in their ears, or even seeing a little girl running through the house. Many electronic voice phenomenons have revealed that there are many more entities in this house than meets the eye.

Proof:

---

History:

 The Roads Hotel is a historic building built in 1893. It was once a railroad layover station. During Prohibition, it became a brothel. Today, the hotel is operated by the Lost Limbs Foundation. The foundation’s mission is to help children who have lost limbs. They will use the money collected from investigations and events to support this cause.

The hotel is believed to be haunted by several different spirits. Guests have reported seeing glimpses of children and women, and hearing disembodied screams and footsteps. A child’s handprint is still on the wall of the hotel’s penthouse.

Proof:

The Roads Hotel is a popular destination for paranormal investigations. Private investigations are available for a fee.

---

History:

The Bristol theater opened in 1896. It was used as a skating rink, music hall, and cinema. Its owners wanted to keep up with the latest advances in technology and continuously bring entertainment to the area.

The theater is believed to be haunted by three spirits. One is a young girl named Beth. She is often seen peering through the curtains at the audience.

Another is a middle-aged woman named Helen. She is thought to be protective of the directors and producers of the theater. She has been spotted on the stage and on the left side of the stage.

A third ghost is a former owner of the theater. He has been seen running through the billiards room at night. He is also a handyman and likes to play with the electrics. He is blamed for any problems in the theater.

Proof:

---

History:

The Tunnelton Tunnel was built in the mid-1800s, and was one of the longest tunnels in the state of Indiana. It was a challenge to build because of the curvature.

According to legend, the tunnel is haunted by the ghost of a man who was killed while the tunnel was being built. The man is believed to roam the tunnel with his head in one hand. 

There is also a legend that claims that a ghostly family was killed on their horse and buggy that crashed into the river nearby. Many people have also claimed to see a mysterious light in the tunnel, with some tourists having also reported strange breakdowns and feelings of dread when approaching the tunnel.

Proof:

Pennhurst Asylum has been featured in many television shows. It has been featured on Ghost Hunters and Ghost Adventures. It is also part of the International Coalition of Sites of Conscience.

---

History:

This 24-room mansion has been the site of many paranormal events and unexplainable occurrences making it one of the most haunted places in Indiana.

The story of Hannah’s slave burial is one that has been passed down from generation to generation in the Hannah family. The story goes that Alexander Hannah built the house as a gift to his wife Elizabeth. They had a difficult pregnancy, and he was unable to produce an heir.

After Alexander’s death in 1895, his property was sold to German immigrant Roman Oehler. The house was listed as a historical landmark by the U.S. Department of Interior in 1978. The house has since been restored and turned into a jewelry store. It is still open to the public on select occasions.

Proof:

The basement of the house is the most active area for paranormal activity. The ghostly apparition of a slave has been spotted on several occasions. The cellar was also the site of a fire that trapped many slaves. The bodies were then buried in simple coffins under the dirt floor.

---

History:

Whether you’re a history buff, or just interested in a haunted historic property, Central State Hospital in Indianapolis is a place to check out.

After serving as an insane asylum for nearly a century, the facility has been redeveloped to serve a number of purposes. It has been turned into shops, apartments, and greenways. The property is also home to a museum, which features a pathological department.

Regardless, many believe the energy from the asylum still impacts the structures in and around the property.

Proof:

Some people claim to have seen an apparition of a woman in the basement of the former hospital. Others have heard screams in the basement. There are also reports of electrical devices turning on and off by themselves.

---

History:

Boone Hutcheson Cemetery is one of the oldest cemeteries in the state. It is also famous for its ghost stories. The cemetery is home to many ghosts, including the spirit of a policeman from the 1950s.

The police officer is said to be on constant patrol. This ghost is seen wearing antique clothes and holding a blue light. He seems harmless, but visitors say he chases them out of the cemetery.

Proof:

---

Go out and explore!

That concludes our list of haunted places in Indiana, but there are plenty of other haunted locations located across the country.

If you’re having trouble finding haunted places be sure to check out our Ultimate Guide to Finding Abandoned Places, or explore other ghost towns across the country.